אטיאס · ATTIAS ATTIAS · אטיאס

Tech, companies and assets

Options, RSUs and shares in divorce

For hi-tech employees, options are sometimes the largest asset in the family. The question is not whether they are divided, but what part, and as of which date.

The central question

An option granted during the marriage that vested after it

Options are usually granted in tranches that vest over several years. For that reason, in almost every hi-tech divorce there are options that were granted during the marriage but vested only after the date of the breakdown. The question is whether that part is the fruit of a joint effort, or an incentive for future work that does not belong to the other spouse.

In a case heard by the Family Court in Beersheba in 2020, it was held that the wife was entitled to half of all the options granted during the marriage, including those that vested after the date of the breakdown. The court rejected the argument that the options were solely an incentive for future work [1]. This is a first-instance ruling, and so each case is examined on its own facts [2].

How it is calculated

The “time rule” and the valuation date

  • The time rule

    Where the vesting period overlaps with the marriage only in part, the divisible part is determined by the ratio between the period within the marriage and the entire vesting period [1].
  • The valuation date

    For options that are not tradable, courts have often preferred to value them as of the date of actual exercise rather than the date of the breakdown. The Supreme Court denied permission to appeal against such a determination (Family Appeal Permission 7482/18) [2][3].
  • Division now or on exercise

    Equalisation can be based on a valuation today, or a mechanism can be set under which each side receives its share when the options are actually exercised. Each route carries a different price in risk and tax.
  • Tax

    The value of an option to an employee is after tax. The rate of tax depends on the allocation track and the date of sale, and so it is examined with an accountant before any number is agreed.

The tax track

Section 102: the same option, a different value

Options for employees are usually allocated under Section 102 of the Income Tax Ordinance. In the capital track, through a trustee, the gain is taxed as a capital gain at 25% (plus surtax where it applies), provided 24 months have passed since the allocation. Exercise before that turns the whole benefit into employment income, at a marginal rate of up to 47% [4].

Why this matters in divorce: an option said to be worth “a million” is worth its holder a very different sum depending on the track and the date of exercise. A controlling shareholder is usually outside Section 102, and then tax is determined under other rules [5]. For that reason the agreement should set the exercise date and the division of the tax, and not only the number of options. Tax on the division of property

What to prepare

The documents needed

  • The option plan

    The grant document, the vesting schedule and the leaver terms (what happens to the options if the employee leaves).
  • Reports from the company

    How many were granted, how many have vested and when, and how many have already been exercised or sold.
  • Expected events

    A funding round, merger or IPO that is under way and may change the value within months.

Questions

Frequently asked questions

My options have not vested yet. Are they included in the equalisation?

Quite possibly, in part. If they were granted during the marriage, there is case law holding that they are divided even if they vested later, according to the time rule [1].

What about RSUs?

RSUs are an allocation of shares that vest over time. The questions are similar: when they were granted, when they vested, and what they are worth after tax.

Is it better to settle on a sum today?

It depends on the company and the risk. A sum today gives certainty, and division on exercise suits cases where value cannot be assessed reliably.

A working meeting with Adv. Attias: 02-5666911 · Contact

Back: Tech, companies and assets