A parent who carries out a judgment given in his or her favour is not an "abductor" under the Hague Convention.
Background. A judgment ordered the children returned to Israel, and the mother did not comply. The court ordered Israeli passports issued for the children, and in summer 2025 the father brought his son back. The mother filed a Hague Convention claim, alleging abduction.
What we did. We represented the father and moved to dismiss in limine. We argued there is no wrongful removal when a parent carries out a final judgment, and that courts in Israel and the US had found the father to be the custodial parent.
Outcome. The claim was dismissed in limine. The court held that the Hague Convention protects children from abduction, not parents from the enforcement of judgments. The mother was ordered to pay ILS 20,000 in costs.